Air carriers are not obligated to refund fees charged by ticket providers
When passengers purchase their flight ticket through a travel agent, the travel agent often charges some additional fees aside from the actual ticket. This can cause problems when the flight is cancelled. In such a case, the passenger can claim the ticket price refunded directly from the air carrier, but the question is whether this also applies to the additional fees? This is considered in a recent ruling from the Court in Kolding.
In 2020, three friends had booked a trip through an online travel agency from Billund to Antalya, departing on 28 April 2020 and returning on 7 May 2020. However, the trip was cancelled due to COVID-19. The air carrier and the passengers agreed that the pandemic was the cause of the cancellation and that the passengers therefore were entitled to a refund of the unused tickets following EU Regulation 241 Article 8, 1.
On the other hand, they did not agree on what should happen to the fee of almost 96 EUR, corresponding to a little more than 500 DKK which the travel agency had charged the passengers in connection with their purchase. Therefore, the case was put before the Court in Kolding in December 2020.
The full cost of the ticket
In their reasoning, the passengers emphasized that Regulation 261/2004 in Article 8, 1 (a) states that there must be a refund of "the full cost of the ticket" for those parts of a specific trip that have not been made.
The regulation does not contain a definition of "the full cost”, so the passengers referred to EU case C-601/17 Harms v. Vueling. In that case, the European Court of Justice ruled that the full cost must be the difference between the amount paid by the passenger and the amount received by the carrier. The court also pointed out that the fee charged by the travel agent is also included in the "full cost" unless the fee is set without the air carrier's knowledge. On this basis, the passengers did not think there could be any doubt that the air carrier should repay the fee. They stressed that they as consumers had no knowledge of the air carrier's workflows and partners. In this connection, they also pointed out that it was the air carrier's task to prove that they were not aware of the fee.
An agreement only entails rights and obligations for those who are a party to the agreement
The air carrier, on the other hand, emphasized that it ought to be the travel agency or ticket intermediary that pays reimbursement to the passengers – as well as any fees, because the air carrier does not have the opportunity to know which agreements have been made between the two parties. The fact that a travel agency chooses to resell an air carrier’s travel service does not mean that the air carrier becomes a party to the agreement between the passenger and the travel agency. The air carrier is only obliged to transport the passenger to the destination stated on the ticket.
The Court in Kolding agreed with this when they stated that the air carrier was not obliged to refund the fee. In that regard, the Court found it crucial that there was no evidence that the air carrier was aware of the existence of the resale fee, its amount or what it covered.
IUNO’s opinion
Based on this case, we can ascertain that it should not be a financial burden for the air carrier that travel agencies and similar ticket intermediaries charge an extra fee. However, it is important to be aware that this is only the case if the air carriers are not aware of the fee. Therefore, IUNO recommends that air carriers do not recognize claims for reimbursement of fees unless the fee is charged in accordance with an agreement with the air carrier.
[The Court in Kolding's judgment of 24 January 2022 in case BS-47822/2022-KOL]
In 2020, three friends had booked a trip through an online travel agency from Billund to Antalya, departing on 28 April 2020 and returning on 7 May 2020. However, the trip was cancelled due to COVID-19. The air carrier and the passengers agreed that the pandemic was the cause of the cancellation and that the passengers therefore were entitled to a refund of the unused tickets following EU Regulation 241 Article 8, 1.
On the other hand, they did not agree on what should happen to the fee of almost 96 EUR, corresponding to a little more than 500 DKK which the travel agency had charged the passengers in connection with their purchase. Therefore, the case was put before the Court in Kolding in December 2020.
The full cost of the ticket
In their reasoning, the passengers emphasized that Regulation 261/2004 in Article 8, 1 (a) states that there must be a refund of "the full cost of the ticket" for those parts of a specific trip that have not been made.
The regulation does not contain a definition of "the full cost”, so the passengers referred to EU case C-601/17 Harms v. Vueling. In that case, the European Court of Justice ruled that the full cost must be the difference between the amount paid by the passenger and the amount received by the carrier. The court also pointed out that the fee charged by the travel agent is also included in the "full cost" unless the fee is set without the air carrier's knowledge. On this basis, the passengers did not think there could be any doubt that the air carrier should repay the fee. They stressed that they as consumers had no knowledge of the air carrier's workflows and partners. In this connection, they also pointed out that it was the air carrier's task to prove that they were not aware of the fee.
An agreement only entails rights and obligations for those who are a party to the agreement
The air carrier, on the other hand, emphasized that it ought to be the travel agency or ticket intermediary that pays reimbursement to the passengers – as well as any fees, because the air carrier does not have the opportunity to know which agreements have been made between the two parties. The fact that a travel agency chooses to resell an air carrier’s travel service does not mean that the air carrier becomes a party to the agreement between the passenger and the travel agency. The air carrier is only obliged to transport the passenger to the destination stated on the ticket.
The Court in Kolding agreed with this when they stated that the air carrier was not obliged to refund the fee. In that regard, the Court found it crucial that there was no evidence that the air carrier was aware of the existence of the resale fee, its amount or what it covered.
IUNO’s opinion
Based on this case, we can ascertain that it should not be a financial burden for the air carrier that travel agencies and similar ticket intermediaries charge an extra fee. However, it is important to be aware that this is only the case if the air carriers are not aware of the fee. Therefore, IUNO recommends that air carriers do not recognize claims for reimbursement of fees unless the fee is charged in accordance with an agreement with the air carrier.
[The Court in Kolding's judgment of 24 January 2022 in case BS-47822/2022-KOL]
Similar
The team
![](/media/22673/siddende_2016.png)
Aage
Krogh
Partner![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Adam
Harding Ryyd Lange
Legal assistant![](/media/29528/amalie_siddende_2023.png)
Amalie
Bjerre Hilmand
Legal advisor![](/media/23704/amalie_siddende_2023.png)
Amalie
Sofie Sveen Kvam
Legal assistant![](/media/29532/amanda_siddende_2023.png)
Amanda
Jepsen Bregnhardt
Legal assistant![](/media/29499/andrea_siddende_2023.png)
Andrea
Brix Danielsen
Legal advisor![](/media/23097/anna_siddende_2023.png)
Anna
Bonander
Legal advisor![](/media/25910/anna_siddende_2023.png)
Anna
Kreutzmann
Senior legal assistant![](/media/23359/anne_siddende_2023.png)
Anne
Voigt Kjær
Senior legal assistant![](/media/23052/anton_siddende_2023.png)
Anton
Winther Hansen
Legal advisor![](/media/29503/ashley_siddende_2023.png)
Ashley
Kristine Morton
Legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Benedicte
Rodian
Senior legal assistant![](/media/17880/bror_siddende_2021.png)
Bror
Johan Kristensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/15171/chris_siddende_2020.png)
Chris
Anders Nielsen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/29536/cille_siddende_2023.png)
Cille
Fahnø
Senior legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Clara
Caballero Stephensen
Legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Ellen
Priess-Hansen
Legal assistant![](/media/22203/elvira_siddende_2022.png)
Elvira
Feline Basse Schougaard
Senior legal advisor![](/media/29540/ema_siddende_2023.png)
Ema
Besic-Ahmetagic
Junior legal advisor![](/media/29565/emma_siddende_2023.png)
Emma
Engvang Hansen
Legal assistant![](/media/17930/emma_siddende_2021.png)
Emma
Frøslev Larsen
Legal manager![](/media/20082/fransine_siddende_2022.png)
Fransine
Andersson
Legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Frederikke
Kirkegaard Thalund
Legal assistant![](/media/23367/frederikke_siddende_2023.png)
Frederikke
Østerlund Haarder
Senior legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Frida
Aas Ahlquist
Legal assistant![](/media/21173/frida_siddende_2022.png)
Frida
Assarson
Legal advisor![](/media/25960/gustav_siddende_2023.png)
Gustav
Vestergaard
Senior legal assistant![](/media/30441/hanna_siddende_2024.png)
Hanna
Honerød Augestad
Junior legal advisor![](/media/23066/isabella_siddende_2023.png)
Isabella
Rocio Nielsen
Junior legal advisor![](/media/25970/johanne_siddende_2023.png)
Johanne
Berner Nielsen
Senior legal assistant![](/media/29625/kaisa_siddende_2023.png)
Kaisa
Nova Ordell Guldbrand Thygaard
Junior legal advisor![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Karl Emil
Tang Nielsen
Legal assistant![](/media/29629/karoline_siddende_2023.png)
Karoline
Halfdan Petersen
Legal manager![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Karoline
Nordved
Legal assistant![](/media/29637/laura_siddende_2023.png)
Laura
Jørgensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Mathias
Bech Linaa
Junior legal advisor![](/media/15730/maya_siddende_2020.png)
Maya
Cecillia Jørgensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/22237/mie_siddende_2022.png)
Mie
Lundberg Larsen
Legal manager![](/media/23526/rosa_siddende_2023.png)
Rosa
Gilliam-Vigh
Legal advisor![](/media/24684/selma_siddende_2023.png)
Selma
Agopian
Senior EU associate![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Selma
Klinker Brodersen
Junior legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Silje
Moen Knutsen
Junior legal advisor![](/media/29653/sille_siddende_2023.png)
Sille
Lyng Mejding
Legal advisor![](/media/26081/simone_siddende_2023.png)
Simone
Bjergskov Nielsen
Senior legal assistant![](/media/29657/sofija_siddende_2023.png)
Sofija
Cabrilo
Legal assistant![](/media/10370/sophia_siddende_2019.png)
Sophia
Maria Dahl-Jensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/26084/stine_siddende_2023.png)