Six-hour delay in sight – no compensation
A passenger arranged his own rebooking when his flight was delayed. The EU Court of Justice ruled that the passenger was not entitled to compensation because the rebooking did not result in a delay of more than three hours compared to the original arrival time.
A passenger was supposed to fly from Düsseldorf to Palma de Mallorca. Before departure, the passenger was informed that the original flight would be delayed by six hours. The passenger took matters into his own hands and rebooked his journey. The passenger arrived with less than three hours delay thanks to the rebooking. However, the passenger still demanded compensation. He argued that he would have been delayed by more than three hours if he had not acted.
The EU Court of Justice's assessment
The EU Court of Justice emphasized that Regulation 261/2004 aims to alleviate passengers' difficulties and serious inconveniences. It may be inconvenient for the passenger to find an alternative flight – but if the delay is less than three hours compared to the original arrival time, it is not a serious inconvenience.
IUNO's opinion
The case demonstrates that passengers are not entitled to compensation if they rebook their own flight and arrive with less than three hours of delay. This should be seen in light of Article 6 of the Regulation on delayed departure, which does not trigger an obligation for airlines to rebook passengers.
IUNO recommends that air carriers carefully assess whether passengers who arrange their own rebooking meet the necessary criteria to be entitled to compensation.
[Ruling of the EU Court of Justice of 25 January 2024 in Case C-54/23]
A passenger was supposed to fly from Düsseldorf to Palma de Mallorca. Before departure, the passenger was informed that the original flight would be delayed by six hours. The passenger took matters into his own hands and rebooked his journey. The passenger arrived with less than three hours delay thanks to the rebooking. However, the passenger still demanded compensation. He argued that he would have been delayed by more than three hours if he had not acted.
The EU Court of Justice's assessment
The EU Court of Justice emphasized that Regulation 261/2004 aims to alleviate passengers' difficulties and serious inconveniences. It may be inconvenient for the passenger to find an alternative flight – but if the delay is less than three hours compared to the original arrival time, it is not a serious inconvenience.
IUNO's opinion
The case demonstrates that passengers are not entitled to compensation if they rebook their own flight and arrive with less than three hours of delay. This should be seen in light of Article 6 of the Regulation on delayed departure, which does not trigger an obligation for airlines to rebook passengers.
IUNO recommends that air carriers carefully assess whether passengers who arrange their own rebooking meet the necessary criteria to be entitled to compensation.
[Ruling of the EU Court of Justice of 25 January 2024 in Case C-54/23]
Similar
The team
![](/media/22673/siddende_2016.png)
Aage
Krogh
Partner![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Adam
Harding Ryyd Lange
Legal assistant![](/media/29528/amalie_siddende_2023.png)
Amalie
Bjerre Hilmand
Legal advisor![](/media/23704/amalie_siddende_2023.png)
Amalie
Sofie Sveen Kvam
Legal assistant![](/media/29532/amanda_siddende_2023.png)
Amanda
Jepsen Bregnhardt
Legal assistant![](/media/29499/andrea_siddende_2023.png)
Andrea
Brix Danielsen
Legal advisor![](/media/23097/anna_siddende_2023.png)
Anna
Bonander
Legal advisor![](/media/25910/anna_siddende_2023.png)
Anna
Kreutzmann
Senior legal assistant![](/media/23359/anne_siddende_2023.png)
Anne
Voigt Kjær
Senior legal assistant![](/media/23052/anton_siddende_2023.png)
Anton
Winther Hansen
Legal advisor![](/media/29503/ashley_siddende_2023.png)
Ashley
Kristine Morton
Legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Benedicte
Rodian
Senior legal assistant![](/media/17880/bror_siddende_2021.png)
Bror
Johan Kristensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/15171/chris_siddende_2020.png)
Chris
Anders Nielsen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/29536/cille_siddende_2023.png)
Cille
Fahnø
Senior legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Clara
Caballero Stephensen
Legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Ellen
Priess-Hansen
Legal assistant![](/media/22203/elvira_siddende_2022.png)
Elvira
Feline Basse Schougaard
Senior legal advisor![](/media/29540/ema_siddende_2023.png)
Ema
Besic-Ahmetagic
Junior legal advisor![](/media/29565/emma_siddende_2023.png)
Emma
Engvang Hansen
Legal assistant![](/media/17930/emma_siddende_2021.png)
Emma
Frøslev Larsen
Legal manager![](/media/20082/fransine_siddende_2022.png)
Fransine
Andersson
Legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Frederikke
Kirkegaard Thalund
Legal assistant![](/media/23367/frederikke_siddende_2023.png)
Frederikke
Østerlund Haarder
Senior legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Frida
Aas Ahlquist
Legal assistant![](/media/21173/frida_siddende_2022.png)
Frida
Assarson
Legal advisor![](/media/25960/gustav_siddende_2023.png)
Gustav
Vestergaard
Senior legal assistant![](/media/30441/hanna_siddende_2024.png)
Hanna
Honerød Augestad
Junior legal advisor![](/media/23066/isabella_siddende_2023.png)
Isabella
Rocio Nielsen
Junior legal advisor![](/media/25970/johanne_siddende_2023.png)
Johanne
Berner Nielsen
Senior legal assistant![](/media/29625/kaisa_siddende_2023.png)
Kaisa
Nova Ordell Guldbrand Thygaard
Junior legal advisor![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Karl Emil
Tang Nielsen
Legal assistant![](/media/29629/karoline_siddende_2023.png)
Karoline
Halfdan Petersen
Legal manager![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Karoline
Nordved
Legal assistant![](/media/29637/laura_siddende_2023.png)
Laura
Jørgensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Mathias
Bech Linaa
Junior legal advisor![](/media/15730/maya_siddende_2020.png)
Maya
Cecillia Jørgensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/22237/mie_siddende_2022.png)
Mie
Lundberg Larsen
Legal manager![](/media/23526/rosa_siddende_2023.png)
Rosa
Gilliam-Vigh
Legal advisor![](/media/24684/selma_siddende_2023.png)
Selma
Agopian
Senior EU associate![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Selma
Klinker Brodersen
Junior legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Silje
Moen Knutsen
Junior legal advisor![](/media/29653/sille_siddende_2023.png)
Sille
Lyng Mejding
Legal advisor![](/media/26081/simone_siddende_2023.png)
Simone
Bjergskov Nielsen
Senior legal assistant![](/media/29657/sofija_siddende_2023.png)
Sofija
Cabrilo
Legal assistant![](/media/10370/sophia_siddende_2019.png)
Sophia
Maria Dahl-Jensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/26084/stine_siddende_2023.png)